Doctor's Orders, Featured
comments 8

Why—Or Why Not—Go Into Anesthesia, by Karen Sibert, MD


Article by Karen Sibert, MD | “Doctor’s Orders” curated by editor Eric Donahue

In case you were wondering: robots won’t replace anesthesiologists any time soon, regardless of what The Washington Post may have to say. There’s definitely a place for feedback and closed-loop technology applications in sedation and in general anesthesia, but for the foreseeable future we will still need humans.

I’ve been practicing anesthesiology for 30 years now, in the operating rooms of major hospitals. Since 1999 I’ve worked at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, a large tertiary care private hospital in Los Angeles.

So what do I want to tell you, the next generation of physicians, about my field?

A “lifestyle” profession?

For starters, I have to laugh when I hear anesthesiology mentioned with dermatology and radiology as one of the “lifestyle” professions. Certainly there are outpatient surgery centers where the hours are predictable and there are no nights, weekends or holidays on duty. The downside? You’re giving sedation for lumps, bumps and endoscopies a lot of the time, which can be tedious. You may start to lose your skills in line placement, intubation and emergency management.

Occasionally, though, if you work in an outpatient center, you’ll be asked to give anesthesia for inappropriately scheduled cases on patients who are really too high-risk to have surgery there. These patients slip through the cracks and there they are, in your preoperative area. Canceling the case costs everyone money and makes everyone unhappy. Yet if you proceed and something goes wrong, you can’t even get your hands on a unit of blood for transfusion. To me, working in an outpatient center is like working close to a real hospital but not close enough — a mixture of boredom and potential disaster.

The path I chose is to focus on high-risk inpatient cases. I especially enjoy thoracic surgery, with the challenges of complex patients and one-lung ventilation. You can bring me the sickest patient in the hospital setting — where I have all the monitoring techniques, resuscitation drugs, blood products, bronchoscopes and anything else I might need — and I’ll be perfectly happy. The downside: a practice like mine tends to be stressful and tiring, and I never know the exact time that the day will end. Hospitals that offer level I trauma and high-risk obstetric care are required to have anesthesiologists in house 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. There’s no perfect world.

What type of person is happy as an anesthesiologist?

Even though women comprised 47 percent of U.S. medical school graduates in 2014, only about 33 percent of the applicants for anesthesiology residency were women. I’d be interested to hear from all of you as to why fields such as pediatrics and OB/GYN tend to be so much more attractive to women, because I genuinely don’t understand it. But I do have a few thoughts as to the type of person who tends to be happy or unhappy as an anesthesiologist.

First of all, you have to like the operating room environment and be able to handle occasional emergencies. If you’re the sort of person who likes making rounds, consulting references and deliberating in the company of a group before you make any decision, then anesthesiology isn’t the job for you. Much of what we do is routine and predictable. But when crises arise, decisions must be made rapidly and the anesthesiologist must direct the efforts of a team of nurses and technicians. I’ve known people who have double board certification in internal medicine and anesthesiology — some are among the smartest and most competent people I’ve ever met, and others never get over the wish to deliberate at length before taking action.

Second, you have to enjoy the company of surgeons. Many jokes are made about surgeons. “Often wrong, but never unsure” is one of the more repeatable ones. Some of the more malignant and abusive traditions of past surgical training no longer persist, so we see less arrogance. But a surgeon still needs to have a sense of confidence and a certain amount of nerve. Male or female, they often think of themselves as the captain of the ship. If you can’t deal with that sort of personality with grace and a bit of humor, you won’t be happy trying to coexist with them. Anesthesiologists need to develop the right balance of backbone and flexibility. Most of the time, I simply think of myself as the physician who’s taking care of the heart, lungs, and the rest of the patient’s needs while the surgeon takes care of the surgical problem. We each have our jobs.

Third, you have to make your peace with the idea that you’re not the person that the patient will think of as his or her doctor. That will be the surgeon, or the obstetrician, or the primary care doctor. My interactions with patients are intense but short-lived. Good interpersonal skills help a great deal, as I need to make each patient comfortable with putting his or her life in my hands after just a few minutes of acquaintance. Odds are, though, that the patient won’t remember much about our interaction.

My work in the operating room becomes quite technical after the moment that the patient loses consciousness, which you might see as a disadvantage. On the other hand, I seldom need to be the person who delivers the diagnosis of cancer or other terrible news to patients and families. Anesthesiologists who specialize in obstetric anesthesia or regional techniques spend more of their time with awake patients, while intensive care specialists and chronic pain specialists often see patients repeatedly over a lengthy course of treatment. That’s a choice you make at the fellowship level.

How to decide on a specialty?

For me, the big decision point in medical school was whether to go into internal medicine and specialize in pulmonary medicine, or whether to go into anesthesiology. The fact that I genuinely enjoyed being in the operating room was the critical factor. When I give a medication through the patient’s IV, it takes effect quickly, and I don’t have to wait until the next visit to the clinic to find out if it worked.

I like managing airways and putting needles in blood vessels, and I enjoy being in the anesthesia “cockpit,” orchestrating a patient’s course through induction, maintenance and emergence. I’m fortunate to work with outstanding teams of surgeons, nurses and technicians. We get to know each other well over time, and there’s a comfortable sort of family cohesiveness to the operating room community. I have the pleasure of focusing on one patient and one procedure at a time, without the constant pressure of an office appointment schedule.

There are some dark clouds on the horizon for anesthesiology, though. My group practices in a physician-only model, more common on the West Coast, where each patient has his or her personal anesthesiologist for the duration of the surgery. That model probably won’t be financially sustainable over time.

Just as nurse practitioners are clamoring for independent practice, nurse anesthetists claim that they can give anesthesia just as well and more cheaply than I can. It’s likely that more and more anesthesiology practices will move to a care team model, where anesthesiologists supervise nurse anesthetists and anesthesiologist assistants. Some hospitals, where states allow it, already allow nurse anesthetists to practice with no anesthesiologist supervision at all. Be prepared for downward pressure on payment rates if these trends continue.

Many anesthesiologists are expanding their footprint outside the operating room and becoming more involved with patient care before and after surgery. Others are active in operating room and hospital leadership, and are going back to school for MBA or MHA degrees. You may want to take a look at information about the expanding role of anesthesiologists in the Perioperative Surgical Home initiative, led by the American Society of Anesthesiologists.

My son, as it happens, is a medical student who just finished his second year. I have no idea what field he will choose. I’ve told him the same things I would tell any other medical student:

  1. Don’t try to pick your field too soon. Keep an open mind, because you won’t really have any idea what you’ll find most interesting until you make your way through clinical rotations.
  2. Don’t waste too much time thinking about money or lifestyle. No lifestyle is pleasant enough if you still have to spend your days doing work you don’t enjoy. Frankly, if you wanted to get rich, you should have gone into investment banking.
  3. If you don’t like medicine now, you’ll never like it. Quit before you start a residency, and do something you want to do, not what you thought would make your parents happy.
  4. If you’re like my husband and me, and being a doctor is the only job you ever wanted, be thankful! It’s a great and honorable profession, and one of the few where maturity and experience are valued. I feel at the peak of my game these days, while in Silicon Valley or pro sports they’re past their prime at 35.
  5. It’s an honor and a privilege to take care of another human being. Always remember that, whatever field you pursue, and please accept all my best wishes for success in your future endeavors.

Karen SDr. Karen Sibert, MD is an associate professor of anesthesiology at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles, and a columnist who writes about politics and medicine.  She is married to Steven Haddy, MD, the chief of cardiac anesthesiology at the University of Southern California.  She is also the mother of three grown children, and the grandmother of two small boys. Dr. Sibert’s work has been published in the The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal, and she has numerous academic publications as well. She enjoys reading Jane Austen’s novels and walking her dog, and dislikes discussions of work-life balance.

Eric Donahue Eric Donahue (9 Posts)

Medical Student Editor

University of Washington School of Medicine


Eric serves as a medical student editor at in-Training and he attends the University of Washington – Class of 2017. In the past he has worked in EMS and international community health. As for the future, a career caring for the community is in the works. He believes writing is an essential expression of human ideas, passion and intelligence. Eric is a husband and father of three.


  • Samantha

    “If you don’t like medicine now, you’ll never like it. Quit before you start a residency, and do something you want to do…”

    This is a nice sentiment. But unfortunately many med students don’t know they don’t like medicine until they’re at least a year or two into med school (if not later), at which time they’ve already accumulated significant debt that can’t be easily paid off with most other jobs.

    Also, from a strictly financial perspective, one can graduate in the bottom half of the class, and still be an MD, and make around a $200k annual salary. That can’t be said for most other professions.

    • Barry

      I agree with the above. A daughter of a colleague is dropping out after two years of medical school. The field of medicine is so large and varied that there should be a niche for almost everyone. To encourage a med student to drop out of medicine because they don’t like medical school at the level they are in is bad advice. It takes some people longer than others to find their niche.

  • Samantha

    If these are combined…

    “The downside: a practice like mine tends to be stressful and tiring, and I never know the exact time that the day will end. Hospitals that offer level I trauma and high-risk obstetric care are required to have anesthesiologists in house 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. There’s no perfect world.”

    “My group practices in a physician-only model, more common on the West Coast, where each patient has his or her personal anesthesiologist for the duration of the surgery. That model probably won’t be financially sustainable over time.”

    “Be prepared for downward pressure on payment rates if these trends continue.”

    …it could mean a stressful future with a lot of time spent in the hospital at high malpractice risk for increasingly lower salaries.

    Lesson for med students: It’s best to do what you love and love what you do, because the lifestyle and salary won’t necessarily be there, and in fact already aren’t in many or most places around the US. The West coast is largely fortunate still, but the East coast and South largely aren’t. Midwest is mixed. But sooner or later the West coast will likely succumb as well.

  • Samantha

    Another thing that’s sad about anesthesiology for me is that hospitals and even many of our colleagues (e.g. surgeons) treat us as something less than physicians. Not always, but often enough that it grates after years and years of this. Anesthesiology is not a field for those who expect respect, as Dr. Sibert rightly alluded to in her post.

    In fact, anesthesiology is a service field and our primary “customers” are surgeons, so we have to do whatever it takes to please them, even if it means staying till very late to do an add-on case, or coming in on the weekend because that’s what the surgeon likes, etc. But the primary people surgeons have to please is patients. The surgeons and in fact any physician with more direct control over patients are the “rainmakers” and that’s who hospitals bend over backwards for. I love anesthesiology as a specialty, and still believe it’s the most interesting field there is, but med students need to keep in mind the practice environment and difficulties inherent in anesthesiology as well. The positive side is you have no patients, but the negative side is you have no patients. The negative means less bargaining power or political capital and so on when it comes to dealing with hospital admin, other physicians, etc. It’s become more a liability than a benefit, in my opinion.

  • Diane Brackett

    I’m a medical student on the east coast, where anesthesiologists usually go from OR to OR, supervising the nurse anesthetists; I had no idea that this isn’t the case elsewhere, as on the west coast. So that was really interesting to learn!

    On another note, I’m strongly considering pathology, so I can definitely relate to the notion that “you have to make your peace with the idea that you’re not the person that the patient will think of as his or her doctor.” I’m still trying to decide how important that is to me.

  • Blake

    I’m a private practice anesthesiologist at a large community hospital that is a cardiac center of excellence as well as joint replacement. My group of 12 MDs is part of and anesthesia care team with nurse anesthetists. My practice is very rewarding as there is the higher risk patients I am allowed to spend more time with (mostly out of necessity but often times out of interest). My practice combines many of the things Dr. Sibert describes but I also get to solve and many problems, put in many more lines, blocks, spinals, epidurals. This keeps me busy throughout the day and the care team model potentially allows me to gain more financially for my work.

    One other big thing in the initial choosing of my specialty to students…. Do you like clinic or do you like to make rounds? I get reminded everyday by my surgical colleagues how beleaguering this can be. A general surgeon friend of mine on call with me last weekend rounded on 70 patients for his group’a service, as well as taking new consults and did to operations…. I felt so bad for him.

  • Pingback: Rise of the Machines | Family Covered Low-Cost Health Plans()

  • Ibukunoluwa Araoye

    Really fantastic discussion! Anesthesiology fascinates me but, I’m still grappling with the idea of being a workhorse for the surgeons (especially if they are the arrogant type).